Replacement Theory / Fearing Indian Americas / Should I Leave Author Media?

Has anyone else noticed the drift of the Author Update show from MAGA conservative leaning, to subtle hints of anti immigrant, to full embrace of the great replacement theory?

In the last episode, Thomas started saying “replacement migration” and targeted Indian Americans and H1B visa holders.

For those of you not up to speed on your hate, “replacement theory” is a conspiracy that espouses that certain forces in the world are actively trying to replace white culture with other cultures, that immigration is some vile evil choice to destroy the white race, water down “our vote,” intermarry with our children and dilute “our bloodline”, take “our land,” take “our country!”

This is based on a few assumptions:

  • There is evil intent from migrants and the people that welcome them (always attributed to left leaning folks, socialists, jews, muslims… in the days of the KKK, even Catholics were targeted)

  • The land is OUR land and must be protected for us (us = white folks)

  • The true religion is OUR religion and it must be protected (read, conservative Christianity, not any other type of christianity and certainly not any other belief system)

Thats a lot of “our” “us” “me” “mine” - for a country that is a pluralistic, multiethnic, secular democracy. Worse, this “our land, our culture, our religion our blood” has been used through history as an excuse for horrible violence.

  • its how the KKK talked about recently freed black Americans.

  • It’s how the Nazis talked about Jewish people.

  • For the last few years, it’s how some want to talk about immigrants.

And it’s having real impacts. Several mass-shooters have used replacement theory in their deranged online screeds and manifestos. Neo-nazis and white nationalist groups with violent histories embrace replacement theory.

And, the cutting edge of this hateful, unchristian, un-American idea is hating Indians and Indian Americans. Two weeks ago I saw an article in my google news feed entitled “Indian Americans Become the Newest Target of Hate.” It seems that, with the souther boarder closed, people need a new boogieman to fear, a new excuse for why things have changed, why things aren’t goin well for them, why the world looks different in frightening ways - the new target, the new excuse, the new online scapegoat is Indian Americans.

If we stop all immigration from India, there will be a new target next week.

I am not saying that everyone who has bought into this thinking IS a horrible person or a racist. Some are just deep into their own online echo chamber on X.

I am saying the idea is racist, it’s hateful, it’s dangerous, and it’s been championed in the past by racist, dangerous, and violet people.

What breaks my heart is that I really like this author media community. I really enjoy supporting other folks and learning from other folks.

It also breaks my heart to see ideas like replacement theory championed by Christians. I think these sort of ideas are a stain on the body of Christ. I want to stand up and say “not all Christians.” I want to stand up and say “there is another way, this isn’t the heart of Christ, this isn’t biblical.”

And maybe that is what I am doing here.

But, maybe I also just need to leave this community. After all, by staying, am I giving support in any way to these ideas?

At any rate, I am wasting too much time writing these posts and it’s probably not good for my blood pressure. For that reason, I am going to throw this one out there and see what yawl think. I probably won’t reply to any replies.