Cozy Mystery: How much Math is Too Much Math?

I’m really looking for responses from readers and writers of cozy mysteries here, although @Thomas Umstattd Jr. is always welcome to chime in.

OK, first off, I am weird. I love math. It is beautiful. It is the universal language. If we ever communicate with aliens, it won’t be in English or Klingon, it will be in math. I’m not an expert by any means, but probably better than the average bear.

I am not my Timothy. She is well educated, super smart, has many different interests, though I’m not sure math is one of them. She is 70. Of the two math problems, she could definitely do the first one, if she were so inclined. Doubtful on the second one.

So here’s the scenario. My FMC has figured the killer must be hiding out in an abandoned copper mine in the Sonoran Desert (Arizona). She has gotten ahold of a map that shows four possible mines. FMC and her bff are trying to narrow it down because there is a ticking clock.

First, they do a simple vector analysis. But this doesn’t give the right solution, because it shows what the ideal location would be, based on the inputs, not the location the bad guy was most likely to choose.

So they turn to a Bayesian inference model, and this is where the math gets tricky. FMC uses the solution to ultimately find the baddy.

Here’s the thing: in my current draft, I actually do the math. The reader is looking at FMC’s screen while she and her sidekick chat and talk it through. The math is correct. Using a Bayesian inference model to find a hideout is a little hinky, but the math works. It took me hours to do it, lol, but my son who went to MIT double checked it. I’m guessing no one will actually stop reading to check my math, but for that one reader out there, I made sure the math is right and the premise is plausible.

Is this too much math to put into a cozy mystery? There is no other math in the book. The FMC gets the rest of her clues the regular cozy mystery way, by questioning people, being observant, etc. She is supposed to be super brilliant, and this is a way to show that. I was thinking most readers will see it, think FMC is very smart, turn the page, and move on.

But I know many people are afraid of math and hate it. I am not trying to get readers to DNF my book because a computer screen is showing some formulas and graphs.

I love it. But I am not the reader.

What do you all think? Keep it or kill my darling?