Short Story Critique (Willing to Critique Swap too!)
Thanks in advance to anyone who reads this! I wrote this earlier in the summer and have returned to it. I… don’t really know how to feel about it, but I like the premise and certain parts. it’s 1800 words, just about.
Anything that could be cut? What’s your emotional reaction to the end? Any way I should/ can speed it up?
‘Welcome home, Julie.” Mr. Roberts opens the door for me, and I step inside. Warm light hits me, and I gaze around the place that my new parents expect me to call home.
It is everything I read about in the stories. A living room, with large, plush couches, and a kitchen big enough to fit my bed in.
Is this my new world?
“How do you like it, Julie?’ Mrs. Roberts glances at me.
I stare out how big it is, how open it is- how clean and fresh it feels. And how wide open the space is… I feel so vulnerable standing in the middle of this big space. And there are no good places to retreat to, no convenient corners or nooks like the orphanage. I am in the open. This There is no place for me. But I choke down the lump in my throat and whisper what I know they want to hear. “It’s beautiful. And cozy. I like it.”
She smiles, and squeezes my hand. “It’s all yours.”
Mr. Roberts passes us, carrying my bags under either arm. ‘Come on up here- I’ll show you your room.” He calls over his shoulder.
My room. A space of my own? Maybe this new world has a place for me after all. But I’m not setting my hopes on it. I trudge up the carpeted stairs after him, and follow him to the second door on the left.
“Here you are.” He sets the bags down, and opens it.
A bed, twice the size of my old one, with a dark blue fuzzy blanket and two white pillows adorning it stands opposite me.
My room.
To the left, a big desk, made of rich, dark brown invites me further in.
My room.
My room. Mine. I turn to Mr. Roberts. “... Thank you.” I can't keep my voice steady.
He nods,, and opens his arms like he’s waiting for a hug and I resist the urge to back-pedal. Instead I stand like a soldier at attention. Stiff. Arms at my sides.
Finally, he drops his arms. ‘Uh… let’s go down to dinner. Your mom’s got the best recipe in the whole city for chicken pot pie, and I think it’s ready.” He forces a corner of his mouth upwards. On the way down, his shoulders slump, and he keeps his hands in his pockets the way I keep my thoughts in my head: like they’re dangerous around others.
I follow him downstairs, wondering about his countenance change, when I refused his touch. He doesn’t get it, does he? Doesn’t know the world I came from.
He barely knows me.
Doesn’t he know that trust is earned? That you have to prove yourself to earn trust?
Well, until he proves himself, I’ll keep it that way.
Dinner is full of good smells, and small talk. Mr. Roberts manages to ask me a question every time I take a bite. Mrs. Roberts lets me breathe a little more, not watching me, just eating and occasionally giving me a smile.
After dinner ends, Mr. Roberts puts a big grin on his face.
Too big. I think I can see a tooth in there.
“Now, Lila. We thought we could spend the whole evening together. We can play games, watch some tv, or just talk. How does that sound?” He asks with another grin that makes my stomach clench.
The whole evening… The whole evening? More small talk? More forced engagement with these strangers who called themselves my parents?
“I… I think I’d like to be in my room tonight… I’m very tired.” I add, trying not to recoil at his suggestion.
“Oh… of course dear.” Both their faces fall. “Have fun…”
I force myself to shuffle up the stairs, or I’ll seem too eager to leave.
When I get into my room, I dig through my bag. Where is it? Where is it? I scrabble at the contents, shoving them around, until I pull it out.
An old notebook, whose spine is in shreds, and the edges of the cover rubbed away in places. I hug it to myself. Time to go back, back to the only trustworthy place I know. The only place that kept me safe.
After sitting at the desk, I open my notebook, set the tip of the pen against the paper and… I hit the floor of the stone gymnasium. The cold concrete walls surrounding me are thick. Safe.
I turn and face the wooden dummy. A firm kick knocks it over.
Again.
I repeat the motion again and again, concentrating on the physical movement, and ignore that twist in my gut. This is where I learned to take care of myself. To defend myself. The world outside of this one isn’t trustworthy. Isn’t safe. At least, not for people like me.
Survival never comes easily. I need to train, to become strong. No one else kept me safe so I stopped learning to expect it. Especially from adults.
After the orphanage director dismissed my getting bullied.
Punch! The dummy wobbles on its stand.
After the nanny whispered that I was a liability. A burden. Nothing more than work.
Kick! The dummy rolls over on its side.
Now I’ve been sent to live with these people. Oh, sure they might have checked that they aren’t dangerous.
Whap! I smack the dummy’s head off with my elbow.
Doesn’t mean they are safe.
Pause. Water.
Nothing is safe, or steady, or reliable… except here. The only place that’s been with me longer than a year. My place. No one to deal with here but me…
I put my pencil down and push my shoulders back, feeling the muscles. They almost seem to ache. Because my world is real. Reliable. Stable.
The room comes into focus. This world… I stare at the marshmallow-like pillows, the poofy comforter, the warm colored walls. This world is not real. Not yet.
I’ll give it a chance. Give them time. But until then? MY world is the real world.
The next day is my first day of school, spent resisting the urge to hide, explaining to teachers how to pronounce my name and resisting the urge to flee all the strangers watching me. They all watch me, their gazes crawling over me like bugs.
After school, I go home, go upstairs and return to my real world. Where I am safe. Where I am strong. The only hard part is… my world doesn’t affect the other world. In the other world, I am nothing, unable to defend myself.
In my world I am a trained warrior. Hardened. Self reliant. I defend myself.
And though I remain all those things in the other world… Somehow it doesn’t translate.
I start to stay in my world more. Before school. After school. Anything to avoid the other world, at least for a while. To avoid the strangers who call themselves my parents. They don’t even know how to interact with me, much less take care of me.
The only thing worse than being in the other world is getting dragged back into it. One moment, immersed in my world. Safe. Strong.
Then dinner time comes, and Mrs. Roberts calls me. No matter how hard I brace myself, I can’t help but be dragged out of my world into the other world.
I submit to it anyways though– I do need to eat.
But sleeping, or trying to, is awful. Staring up at the ceiling in the dark, waiting for my brain to shut off, to relax… It takes forever. So after what feels like an hour of trying one night, I stuff my blanket under the door, and turn on the light. I sit at my desk… and go back. Back to my world. Where sleep is not needed, where control is mine, where I am not threatened.
—----------------------------------------------------------------
That is how we find her in the morning. Still writing. She looks like a ghost. Hollow, pale. I almost think she’s translucent. We can’t let her go to school in that state. So I tell Joseph to call the school. Say she is sick.
And while he called, I sat on the bed and looked at her. Our girl. My girl. I’d fantasized days going on walks, having mother daughter moments. I wanted her to feel safe, to feel loved… and that is why I let her stay in her world. It made her the happiest.
But it drains her. Her skin looks paler than a piece of chalk. Her eyes look hollow… and so tired. Somehow she emerges from her world, the world in her writing, more fragile than ever.
Maybe she really is sick.
I sit, and watch her write. It’s like the pen is controlling her. Forcing her to go on. She doesn’t even seem aware of what she’s doing. Just stares at something I can’t see and continues to mechanically., write. I want to take the pen away… but who knows what that would do to her. It already exhausted her to come back into this world.. If I forced it, she could snap.
Joseph finds me and sits. He puts his arm over my shoulder and we watch her.
“She’s like a ghost, Joseph.” I whisper, drawing my knees up to my chest. “She doesn’t see us… or hear us.”
“She fears us.” His voice is a whisper in my ear.
We sit, and I watch her more. There’s no joy in her face. Just a kind of certain grimness, as if she is required to write, as if her safety depends on it.
“Come on. We need breakfast.” Joseph pulls me away from her, and I relent, following him down to the kitchen.
He burns the hashbrowns, and my pancakes look charred, but we eat anyway.
And then we sit and look at each other.
“She’s like a ghost… Joseph… I can’t stand it. She’s so… so fragile… so distant.”
Joseph nods and sits next to me again. “We should check on her. It’s late, and she needs to eat.”
We creep up to the door and I freeze. “I don’t hear it anymore.” I whisper.
“What?” He beds his head down next to me.
“Her.. grunts. You know, how she always sounded like she was fighting something?”
“Maybe she stopped… Just open the door.”
I edge the door open.
Nothing.
‘What do you mean nothing?” Joseph pushes past me. At the sight of the empty chair he stops.
We check the closet. Under the bed.
The notebook is there. But the pencil is gone.
I sink down onto her bed and stare at the empty space where she sat.
—------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kick. Punch. Slash with elbows. Repeat. The noise echoes in the room. Again. The room demands it. I barely manage to get a drink of water before I feel the insistence. Again.
The dummy never falls apart, never even gets a dent.
Kick. Punch. Keep your guard up.
I have to stay safe. I have to stay strong. This is my world.
This is the only world.