Cover Feedback - Two Versions (and a Timothy )

So, I have two cover drafts and I would love your feedback. The book is a memoir. The egg element is from the book. My ideal reader/Timothy is a college-educated Christian living in Seattle, 38 years old. Not comfortable with simple answers. Attends church regularly but has concerns about where evangelicalism is headed in USA. Loves Jesus. Leans liberal-ish. Reads lots of books, including some self-help and personal growth.

Option One:

Option Two

I will share my thoughts after hearing your insight and feedback. I have some things I like and some questions/concerns about each cover. Thanks for your wisdom, insight, ideas, questions, and feedback.