Substack: is it a blog? Or an email newsletter?
I’ve been Stacking for 3+ years. It’s been great. Most of my debut novel purchases have come from my newsletter readers or fellow Substackers. But when I watch/read “How To” material for newsletters, I scratch my head in frustration.
My “posts” are about half newsy/update/thought-life items, usually written with an attempt at casual enthusiasm or humor, sometimes more serious/memoir-esq. The other half are my responses to the historical fiction I’ve been reading.
My Stack is targeted toward historical fiction readers who enjoy stories set outside the usual times/places. (No World Wars, puleeze!) I rarely write formal reviews. My articles (see – I just called them articles) often compare/connect themes/ideas between books I’ve recently read. These can sometimes shift into more serious tones. I make reference to my own work when there is a legit connection.
So, I have newsy letters and more formal articles. When I write the articles, I usually launch right in without chatty/newsy intros. I suppose these feel less personal when they land in the inbox, but they feel more professional without all of that when found on the website where the context is much more blog/article vibe. This is evergreen material.
(If you don’t know: Substack is an email newsletter system that also posts those emails to a web based site which creates a website/blog-like space. lausanne@substack.com for example)
I feel like adding chatty/personal stuff at the front of these articles diminishes the tone and thought given to them.
Sigh. So, videos like Thomas’ recent Novel Marketing video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XSkGXrtr5-k&t=895s) make me despair. I feel my web evergreen material needs the more serious tone of my historical fiction articles. But likely don’t feel as personal when landing in the email.
I don’t have a huge following, but I get very few unsubs and have a pretty consistent 28-30% open rate no matter what I write.
I suppose I could include the chatty intro to the emails, then edit those out from the articles once they land on the web as evergreen?
It is just me? Is anyone else mulling this question?