How the Fourth Turning Explains the Mainstream Entertainment Collapse

Here is a 1,000 word summary of our 9,300 word blog post on Zeitgeist.

Question: For those of you who read the AuthorMedia blog, which do you like better? Long or short?


Understanding Reader Trends: Writing Books That Will Sell in the Future

Writing a book is a long-term investment, often taking years from conception to publication. With changing reader preferences and cultural shifts, authors must anticipate future trends to ensure their work remains relevant upon release. This blog post explores historical cycles, current cultural changes, and how writers can align their stories with the emerging zeitgeist to avoid commercial failure.

The Era of the "Flopbuster"

Recent years have seen unprecedented failures in the entertainment industry, from blockbuster films to AAA video games. These "flopbusters" indicate a significant cultural shift, with large media companies failing to align their content with audience expectations.

Notable Flopbusters in Gaming and Film

  • Video Games: Concord, Skull and Bones, and Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League have collectively lost over a billion dollars due to being out of sync with modern tastes.

  • Movies: Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny, The Marvels, and Joker 2 suffered massive financial losses, proving that franchises and known IPs are no longer surefire successes.

  • Books: While book industry losses are less visible, major publishers rely on backlist sales, suggesting new releases are underperforming.

Understanding Historical Cycles: The Fourth Turning

The theory of secular cycles, particularly The Fourth Turning by Strauss and Howe, explains that societies move through four generational phases over 80-year cycles:

  1. The High (Spring): A period of strong institutions and collective unity.

  2. The Awakening (Summer): A cultural revolution that challenges established norms.

  3. The Unraveling (Autumn): Individualism rises, and institutions weaken.

  4. The Crisis (Winter): A societal upheaval leads to the rebuilding of institutions.

We are currently entering the Fourth Turning, a period marked by uncertainty, conflict, and the restructuring of societal norms. Understanding this shift helps predict which types of stories will resonate with readers.

Why Are "Flopbusters" Failing?

Many of today's failing films, games, and books were created under the assumption that progressive cultural shifts would continue indefinitely. However, cultural momentum has shifted, and the themes that resonated in the past decade—such as deconstructionist storytelling, antiheroes, and subversion—are losing appeal.

The Shift from Antiheroes to True Heroes

  • Third-Turning Preferences: Audiences favored morally ambiguous antiheroes like Walter White (Breaking Bad) and Tony Soprano (The Sopranos).

  • Fourth-Turning Preferences: Readers seek aspirational, self-sacrificing heroes like Captain America, reflecting a longing for moral clarity and leadership.

Writing for the Fourth Turning: Tropes That Will Resonate

1. The Rise of Self-Sacrificing Heroes

Characters who fight for the greater good, rather than acting out of self-interest, will gain popularity. Unlike antiheroes, they will be driven by duty, not personal vengeance.

2. A Shift in Villains: From Complex to Unambiguously Evil

  • Recent video game successes (Helldivers 2, Space Marines 2) feature villains who are purely evil, indicating a shift away from morally gray antagonists.

  • In past Fourth Turnings, villains were clear-cut threats (e.g., Nazis in World War II-era films).

3. Postmodern Subversion Fatigue

  • Readers are tired of cynical, deconstructive storytelling.

  • Authentic, hopeful stories are becoming more appealing.

4. The Revival of Arthurian and Classic Hero Myths

  • Stories featuring noble, unifying leaders like King Arthur will likely resonate.

  • The Gray Champion, a literary figure who returns during times of crisis, could be a powerful motif in contemporary fiction.

Dystopian Fiction: A Prime Opportunity

Historically, Fourth Turnings have been marked by the popularity of dystopian literature. However, true dystopian fiction differs from modern YA dystopian stories in that it critiques utopian ideals:

  • Past Fourth-Turning Dystopias: 1984, Animal Farm, Brave New World, and Fahrenheit 451 revealed the dark side of supposed utopias.

  • Current Potential: Writers who critique contemporary ideological extremes may create the next Orwellian classic.

The Role of Nostalgia and Escapism

During crises, people often turn to nostalgic or escapist literature:

  • The Hobbit (1937) provided lighthearted adventure during the Great Depression.

  • Lord of the Rings (1954-1955) was more complex, aligning with the rebuilding optimism of the First Turning.

  • World War II Nostalgia is on the rise, suggesting a market for stories centered around unity, sacrifice, and resilience.

Gender Roles in Storytelling: A Changing Landscape

Romance fiction, a massive industry, is also experiencing a shift. Readers are moving away from "girl boss" protagonists and toward traditional gender dynamics:

  • TikTok Trends: A rise in interest in traditional relationships and homemaking suggests changing attitudes.

  • Romance Readers' Requests: Female readers increasingly prefer male heroes who lead, protect, and sacrifice.

Hollywood’s Struggle and Publishing’s Opportunity

Hollywood’s failure to adapt to changing audience expectations presents an opportunity for novelists. Many big-budget films rely on outdated storytelling models, leading to repeated financial failures. Authors can capitalize on this by writing the types of stories that readers are now craving:

  • Moral clarity

  • Unifying leaders

  • Self-sacrificing heroes

  • Escapist adventure

Final Takeaways: Writing the Next Bestseller

  1. Study Past Fourth-Turning Hits: Look at books and films that were popular 80 years ago to understand emerging reader preferences.

  2. Write Aspirational Heroes: The morally ambiguous antihero is waning; self-sacrificing heroes are rising.

  3. Create Clear Villains: Audiences want to see evil defeated without moral ambiguity.

  4. Avoid Postmodern Subversion: Readers are tired of irony and cynicism—they want sincerity.

  5. Embrace Hopeful Storytelling: Offer a vision of a better future, even in dystopian settings.

By understanding historical cycles and cultural shifts, authors can position their books for success, ensuring they resonate with the readers of tomorrow.