Author Newsletter

Main Question: Are reader magnets useless and bonus content more effective for gaining email subscribers?


Context:

Recently, I've noticed many authors struggling to maintain their readership of their newsletters, especially if they got those readers from a Kingsumo giveaway, Booksweeps, or even Bookfunnel.

I listened to Thomas Umstadtt’s podcast interviewing the maker of Book funnel and I heavily believe in newsletters.

However, I’ve been wondering if the reader magnet truly works, even if you swap with people in your genre.

I've had this problem myself. I certainly gained some actual readers from these sources, but it's maybe 1 for every 100 I've attained.

Then, I heard from some other authors who have also struggled with this, often losing readers every email (which I know happens even to the best of us, but at quite a significant rate).

So I really thought about it and tried to put myself in the reader's shoes. What author newsletters do I subscribe and stay subscribed to?

Then it hit me: only authors I know and love already. I discovered their books on IG, through a sale, or somewhere else. I read their books. I loved their books. I then went to subscribe to their newsletter.

This made me wonder: are other readers like me? They only subscribe if they REALLY love an author's book? Have we been doing this whole newsletter thing completely backwards? Should we be offering bonus content at the back of our books to gain subscribers instead of trying to create reader magnets to entice them, only for them to sit on the unread section of Kindle Ebooks?

What do you think?

P.S. I do subscribe to nonfiction newsletters for their content. I am not counting these, only fiction newsletters.